Social distancing boosts quarantine effect on COVID-19 curve: COCHRANE rapid analysis

  • Nussbaumer B, & et al
  • Cochrane Collaboration
  • 9 abr. 2020

  • de Liz Scherer
  • Clinical Essentials
El acceso al contenido completo es sólo para profesionales sanitarios registrados. El acceso al contenido completo es sólo para profesionales sanitarios registrados.

Takeaway

  • Early quarantine combined with other preventative public health measures (e.g., physical distancing, community closures) forms the optimal strategy for reducing COVID-19 morbidity and mortality.
  • Evidence grade is low-very low in this Cochrane rapid analysis.

Why this matters

  • Quarantine alone might be insufficient to contain SARS-CoV-2 transmission and acquisition.
  • Especially those with suspected exposure should practice physical distancing, avoid community gatherings, and quarantine as much as possible.

Key results

  • 29 studies (10 on COVID-19, 15 SARS, 2 SARS/other infectious diseases, 2 MERS).
  • With quarantine only:
    • Case reductions (4 studies) from 44% (COVID-19) to 81% (SARS).
    • Mortality reductions (2 studies) from 31%-34% (COVID-19) to 63% (SARS).
  • Quarantine + other measures (4 studies): 
    • +case isolation, social distancing: 67% case reduction (ages ≥70, 1 study).
    • +closures, mass gathering cancellations, travel restrictions: R 0 reduced from 2.9 to 2.3 in 2 weeks (1 study).
    • +closures: peak of onward transmission reduced by 29.9%.
    • +restricting travelers from ongoing outbreak countries: small effect.

Study design

  • Cochrane rapid review evaluating effects (transmission, mortality, resource utilization) of quarantine alone or in combination with other measures in:
    • Contacts of confirmed/suspected COVID-19 or persons living in high transmission areas;
    • Returning travelers from countries with declared outbreaks.
  • Funding: Cochrane Collaboration.

Limitations

  • Time constraints.
  • Titles limited to English, Chinese languages.
  • Confounding likely.